Full Menu
Browse Johnny's Full Menu Anytime
Explore Johnny's full menu, check pricing anytime, and order online when you're ready.
Pizza
Specialty Pizza & Build Your Own
Supreme
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, green peppers, onions, black olives, mushrooms
6 Cut$14.56
8 Cut$18.72
12 Cut$22.88
16 Cut$28.08
1/2 Sheet$30.16
Full Sheet$43.68
Calzone$14.56
8 Cut Gluten Free$22.88
Meaty
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon
6 Cut$14.56
8 Cut$18.72
12 Cut$22.88
16 Cut$28.08
1/2 Sheet$30.16
Full Sheet$43.68
Calzone$14.56
8 Cut Gluten Free$22.88
Veggie
Mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, onions, banana peppers
6 Cut$14.56
8 Cut$18.72
12 Cut$22.88
16 Cut$28.08
1/2 Sheet$30.16
Full Sheet$43.68
Calzone$14.56
8 Cut Gluten Free$22.88
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Grilled chicken, bacon, onions, ranch dressing
6 Cut$14.56
8 Cut$18.72
12 Cut$22.88
16 Cut$28.08
1/2 Sheet$30.16
Full Sheet$43.68
Calzone$14.56
8 Cut Gluten Free$22.88
BLT
Bacon, ham, lettuce, tomato, mayo, garlic butter sauce
6 Cut$14.56
8 Cut$18.72
12 Cut$22.88
16 Cut$28.08
1/2 Sheet$30.16
Full Sheet$43.68
Calzone$14.56
Philly Cheese Steak
Ribeye steak, green peppers, onion, aglio sauce, horseradish on side
6 Cut$14.56
8 Cut$18.72
12 Cut$22.88
16 Cut$28.08
1/2 Sheet$30.16
Full Sheet$43.68
Calzone$14.56
Hawaiian Baby Rays
Ham, bacon, shredded provolone, pineapple, roasted red peppers
6 Cut$14.56
8 Cut$18.72
12 Cut$22.88
16 Cut$28.08
1/2 Sheet$30.16
Full Sheet$43.68
Sweet Baby Rays BBQ
Premium chicken, cheddar cheese, shredded provolone cheese
6 Cut$14.56
8 Cut$18.72
12 Cut$22.88
16 Cut$28.08
1/2 Sheet$30.16
Full Sheet$43.68
3 Cheese & Spinach
Aglio sauce, baby spinach, tomatoes, 3 cheese blend
6 Cut$14.56
8 Cut$19.76
12 Cut$23.92
16 Cut$28.08
1/2 Sheet$30.16
Full Sheet$43.68
8 Cut Gluten Free$23.92
3 Cheese and Broccoli
See Lent section when featured seasonally
6 Cut$13.52
8 Cut$19.76
12 Cut$23.92
16 Cut$28.08
1/2 Sheet$30.16
Full Sheet$43.68
Flat Bread$13.52
8 Cut Gluten Free$19.76
Cuban
Mayo, mustard, ham, pulled pork, pickles, swiss, 3 cheese blend
6 Cut$14.56
8 Cut$19.76
12 Cut$23.92
16 Cut$28.08
1/2 Sheet$30.16
Full Sheet$43.68
Margherita
Available on pizza and flatbread
6 Cut$14.56
8 Cut$19.76
12 Cut$23.92
16 Cut$28.08
1/2 Sheet$30.16
Full Sheet$43.68
Caprese
Available on pizza and flatbread
6 Cut$14.56
8 Cut$19.76
12 Cut$23.92
16 Cut$28.08
1/2 Sheet$30.16
Full Sheet$43.68
Grilled Chicken with Spinach & Feta
Aglio sauce, grilled chicken, baby spinach, red onions, cheese blend, feta cheese
6 Cut$14.56
8 Cut$19.76
12 Cut$23.92
16 Cut$28.08
1/2 Sheet$30.16
Full Sheet$43.68
8 Cut Gluten Free$23.92
Gyro Pizza
Pizza sauce, gyro meat, onions, tomato, cheese, feta, tzatziki
6 Cut$14.56
8 Cut$19.76
12 Cut$23.92
16 Cut$28.08
1/2 Sheet$30.16
Full Sheet$43.68
8 Cut Gluten Free$23.92
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Breaded chicken, buffalo sauce, mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese, onions, tomato
6 Cut$14.56
8 Cut$19.76
12 Cut$23.92
16 Cut$28.08
1/2 Sheet$30.16
Full Sheet$43.68
8 Cut Gluten Free$23.92
Reuben Pizza
Thousand Island dressing, corned beef, swiss cheese blend
6 Cut$14.56
8 Cut$19.76
12 Cut$23.92
16 Cut$28.08
1/2 Sheet$30.16
Full Sheet$43.68
Biscuit & Gravy Pizza
Sausage gravy, biscuits, sausage, bacon, cheese
6 Cut$13.52
8 Cut$19.76
12 Cut$23.92
16 Cut$28.08
1/2 Sheet$30.16
Full Sheet$43.68
Flat Bread$13.52
Cheeseburger Bacon Pizza
Ground beef, bacon, tomato, onion, pickle, cheddar, provolone, mozzarella
6 Cut$14.56
8 Cut$19.76
12 Cut$23.92
16 Cut$28.08
1/2 Sheet$30.16
Full Sheet$43.68
8 Cut Gluten Free$23.92
Teriyaki Chicken Pizza
Johnny's secret teriyaki sauce, grilled chicken, onion, green peppers, cheese
6 Cut$14.56
8 Cut$19.76
12 Cut$23.92
16 Cut$28.08
1/2 Sheet$30.16
Full Sheet$43.68
Flat Bread$13.52
Meatball Parma Johnny Pizza
Pizza sauce, meatballs, pepperoni, cheese
6 Cut$14.56
8 Cut$19.76
12 Cut$23.92
16 Cut$28.08
1/2 Sheet$30.16
Full Sheet$43.68
Flat Bread$13.52
Italian Pizza
Aglio, pepperoni, salami, ham, tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, 3 cheese blend
6 Cut$14.56
8 Cut$19.76
12 Cut$23.92
16 Cut$28.08
1/2 Sheet$30.16
Full Sheet$43.68
Flat Bread$13.52
Build Your Own Pizza
6 Cut$9.87
8 Cut$12.47
12 Cut$15.59
16 Cut$18.71
1/2 Sheet$20.79
Full Sheet$29.11
8 Cut Gluten Free$15.59
Calzone$9.87
Extra Cheese
6 Cut$2.09
8 Cut$2.70
12 Cut$3.13
16 Cut$3.65
1/2 Sheet$4.17
Full Sheet$6.25
Topping Prices
6 Cut$1.57
8 Cut$2.09
12 Cut$2.56
16 Cut$3.13
1/2 Sheet$3.39
Full Sheet$5.21
Half toppings are half the topping price, rounded up.
Meat Toppings
Pepperoni
Sausage
Ham
Ground Beef
Chicken
Bacon
Veggie Toppings
Green Peppers
Onions
Tomato
Banana Peppers
Jalapeño
Mushrooms
Black Olives
Pineapple
Roasted Red Peppers
Sauce Choice
Red Sauce
White Sauce
Cheese Bread
Small$7.80
Medium$10.40
Large$13.52
Flat Breads
Signature Flat Breads
All flat breads are $13.52.
Appetizers
Starters, Baskets & Quesadillas
Burgers
Burgers Come With Chips or Fries
Cheese choices: American, cheddar, swiss, provolone, pepper jack. Extra cheese add $1.05.
Subs / Wraps
Comes With Chips or Fries
Gyro
Traditional or Chicken Gyro
Salads
Fresh Salads
Add chicken +$5.20. Dressings: Ranch, Italian, Blue Cheese, Poppyseed, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Caesar, Honey Mustard.
Pastas
All Pastas Come With Side Salad & Garlic Bread
Your choice of penne or fettuccine. Add meatballs or sausage for $4.16.
Wings
Traditional or Boneless
Fried Chicken & Ribs
Dinners & Ribs
Fish
Seafood & Fish Dinners
Sides
Sides & Add-Ons
Soup
Homestyle Soup
Desserts
Sweet Finish
Beverages
Drinks
Kids Meals
For The Little Ones
Breakfast
Breakfast Favorites
Catering
Feed The Whole Group
Ask us about catering trays, pizza packages, wings, pasta, salads, and more for parties, events, and gatherings.
Weekly Specials
Limited-Time Offers
Meal Deals
Combo Style Favorites
Pierogies
Savory Pierogies
Reuben
Reuben Favorites
Lent
Seasonal Lent Features
St. Patrick's
St. Patrick's Favorites
Ice Cream